Will this year's GOTY go to the indie or the AAA blockbuster?
Set your conviction — it's your Rep on the line
Critics adore the indie; players logged 10x more hours on the AAA. GOTY juries lean critic-heavy lately.
Top arguments
Conviction over consensus. Tag me when the realities land.
Indie takes GOTY. The narrative voters can't resist a comeback story.
AAA wins on raw hours played, the critics just won't admit it.
Day-one patch is bigger than the base game. Classic.
AAA wins on raw hours played, the critics just won't admit it.
Indie takes GOTY. The narrative voters can't resist a comeback story.
AAA wins on raw hours played, the critics just won't admit it.
Indie. The narrative voters can't resist a comeback story.
AAA wins on raw hours played, the critics just won't admit it.
Patch gets reverted in 48h, the community is already revolting.
Indie takes GOTY. The narrative voters can't resist a comeback story.
Consensus here is lazy. I'm fading the crowd and I'll be back to collect when this resolves.
AAA wins on raw hours played, the critics just won't admit it.
Hot take incoming, but the consensus here is just lazy. Fade the crowd.
Indie takes GOTY. The narrative voters can't resist a comeback story.
Day-one patch is bigger than the base game. Classic.
The Ref's read is doing a lot of heavy lifting for the cowards in here.
I've been right about this lane before and I'll be right again. Tag me at close.
AAA wins on raw hours played, the critics just won't admit it.
AAA wins on raw hours played, the critics just won't admit it.